Abstract
This
research paper discusses the causes of false convictions. Eyewitness testimonies is one cause because it
is inaccurate due to psychological factors and police tactics. A couple
psychological factors that are going to be discussed is stress, reconstructive
memory, misleading questions, and weapon focus. These psychological factors
were studied by psychologists in experiments to see if they were valid factors
preventing eyewitness testimonies from being accurate. They came to the
conclusion that these factor did cause eyewitness testimonies to be ineffective.
Another factor that is going to be discussed is the police tactics used during
an interrogations. Unskilled police use tactics that wrongfully convicts
innocent people. They are biased and have a false sense of confidence when
looking for behavioral cues that supposedly shows if a person is lying. These
behavior cues are not always accurate. The police conduct stressed induced
interrogations so the suspect can confess when they might be innocent. They use
negative and positive incentives
where they might pressure a person to feel guilty for a crime, but also lessen
the severity of the crime and sympathizes with the suspect to make the suspect
confess. There are varies cases where people were falsely accused of a crime,
but later on was exonerated by DNA. One case that are going to be discussed is
the Marvin Anderson were police used tactic to wrongfully convict an innocent
person.
False Convictions
There are many
falsely accused people in eyewitness testimonies and in police interrogations each
year that end up facing years in jail or even face the death penalty. In
Eyewitness testimonies people testify in a court of an event they witnessed.
This can also occur in a police station where someone is to identify a perpetrator
in a lineup. This type of practice is always not so accurate because it falsely
accuses people. This is because there are some psychological factors that can
affect eyewitness testimonies including stress, reconstructive memory, weapon
focus, and misleading questions. Police tactics also is another major reason
that leads to false convictions. They are not trained properly and use methods
that are not appropriate to conduct an interrogation. Due to psychological factors that cause
eyewitness testimonies to be inaccurate and police tactics used in
interrogations innocent people are falsely accused.
There are various psychological factors that cause
eyewitness to be inaccurate. One psychological factor is stress
and anxiety. Deffenbacher (1983) discovered after analyzing twenty one studies
that “stress-performance relationship followed an inverted-U function” shown in the Yerkes Donson Curve (1908)
This
graph shows that efficiency of memory increases along with stress up to a certain
point (optimal level) where there is too much stress that it causes the
efficiency of memory to decline. That means that one can develop a better
memory with the increase of stress, but only up to a certain point called the
optimal level. Clifford and Scott (1978) conducted a study where people saw a
violent attack in a film and remembered fewer of the 40 items of information about
the event compared to a control group that witnessed a version of a film that
was not so stressful (Mcleod,
2009 p.1). In a real criminal event people will most likely become more
stressed which would cause more of an effect on the memory than watching a
film. This would cause an eyewitness testimony to be inaccurate because very
few information will be remembered. People would not be able to identify a
perpetrator properly and possibly accuse an innocent person. This is why memory
has a great effect in the eyewitness testimonies.
Bartlett’s theory of reconstructive memory is a
psychological factor that is important in the understanding of how accurate and
reliable eyewitness testimony is. Recalling can depend on someone’s own
interpretation of something. This can come from what they have experienced and
learned in life. As human beings one may not remember everything exactly how it
was seen. Liptak (2011) stated, “Memory is not a videotape. It is fragile at
best, worse under stress and subject to distortion and contamination.” This is
because one stores information into schemas, which is storing unfamiliar
information into something one can make sense of with prior knowledge one has
about the world. This leads people to change their memory so it can make sense
to them. These schemas can also be prejudice because schemas can be determined
by social values, beliefs, stereotypes, and expectations (Mcleod, 2009 p.1).
This explains why eyewitness testimonies are unreliable because more than
75,000 eyewitnesses identify a suspect in a criminal event each year, and a
third of the time the identifications are wrong (Liptak, 2011 p.1). People’s memory are inaccurate and they might
think they remembered how an event occurred when they really did not. This can
lead people to give false information to police about how an event occurred.
For example, a witness might accuse a person of committing a crime
intentionally when they might have done it accidently. A witness might state
that a bus driver intentionally hit a biker, when really the bus driver did not
see the biker go in front of the bus. This demonstrates that people can interpret
an event differently and give false statements to police that can lead to a
person’s arrest.
One study Barlett (1932) did to prove his theory of
reconstructive memory was in ‘War of the Ghosts’ study where the participants
heard a North American folk tale called ‘War of the Ghosts’ and then had to
tell it to somebody else and so on. All the participants ended up recalling it
differently. The story became shorter, parts of the story was changed to make
sense of it or even completely taken out. The part about ghosts was taken out
because it was hard to interpret, but more familiar parts of the story were
kept. Some of the eyewitnesses remembered familiar statements such as “not
going because he hadn’t told his parents where he was going” (Mcleod, 2009
p.1). This shows that memory is
unreliable because we interpret things into something that we can understand,
make sense of, and fits our expectations. Witnesses can give false information,
like stated before and cause an innocent person to get sentenced to jail.
Weapon focus is
another psychological factor where people tend to focus on a weapon during an
event and lose concentration on other important details. A study was shown
where participants were shown varies slides. In one slide a customer in a
restaurant was holding a gun. In another slide the same customer was holding a
checkbook. The participants who saw the gun version slide were less likely to
select the customer in a police lineup than the participants who saw the
checkbook version. This was because the participants who were shown the gun
version slide were more focused on the gun and excluded other important details
in the picture (Mcleod, 2009 p.1). This can cause innocent people to be
convicted because a person who did not remember the perpetrator in an event
might just choose a random person in a police lineup. This can occur because a
witness might feel pressured to pick a person in a in a lineup by police, which
has happened before.
In the Loftus
and Palmer study it proves that eyewitness testimony can be unreliable due to the
psychological factor leading questions. In the Lofus and Palmer study both
authors stated, "If someone is exposed to new information during the
interval between witnessing the event and recalling it, this new information
may have marked effects on what they recall. The original memory can be modified,
changed or supplemented" (Loftus and Palmer, 2010 p.1). For example, in
this study, students were asked to view a video of a car accident. They were
then asked how fast the car was going by using certain verbs like contacted,
hit and smashed. The students that were asked how fast were the cars driving
when they smashed each other stated it was 40mph, as oppose to when asked how
fast the cars were driving when they came into contact where the students
stated it was 31mph (Loftus and Palmer, 2010 p.1). These misleading questions
show that people can give false statements by the way they are questioned.
Police can have a great effect in this when they are asking a witness to
describe an incident that occurred. This misleading questions can cause a
witness to state that an accident was intentional because a person was speeding
when they struck a person, when the person really might have drove under the
limit but just lost control of their car. This false statement can cause an
innocent person to go to jail.
Police have a great effect on eyewitness
testimonies because they can hint at an eyewitness to select a suspect in a
police lineup. The police are the ones who organize the lineup and usually are
the ones who caught the prime suspect, making them invested in the eyewitness
selecting their choice. The police should have a double blind
scientific experiment at a lineup so neither the police or witness know that
the suspect is in the lineup. The famous psychologist Loftus even believes that
there should be no police involved because it wrongfully convicts people (Bohannon,
2014 p.1). People tend to listen to the police when they pick a person from a
lineup because they think the police are trained and know what they are doing. This
can lead to false convictions because police might be wrong on choosing a
suspect.
Police officers
receive little training in the academy on interrogations. They only receive
more specialized training when they are promoted to a detective. Police are supposed to conduct interrogations
only when they have done investigation and suspect that the suspect is guilty
of the crime. Police determines if a person seems guilty if they have possible
evidence, witnesses, and informants. Other times it is based on a clinical hunch
that is formed during a pre-interrogation interview in which questions are
asked like, “What do you think should happen to this person that committed this
crime?” These types of questions are “behavior provoking” questions where the
suspect’s behavior is observed to determine if they are lying. These behaviors
include, frozen position, fidgety movements, and gaze aversion. Research has
proven that these behavioral cues are not always accurate. It is only 54%
accurate of distinguishing the truth and training in this area would not
improve the accuracy of determining behavioral cues (Kassin,
2009 p. 3). With little training police can falsely accuse an innocent person
easily. Their tactics on picking up on behavioral cues shows that it is
unreliable and can also cause there to be false accusations. This is a concern
in the legal system because many people have been falsely accused and are
continuing to be accused because of these tactics used and not enough training
given to police.
Police
conduct stressed induced interrogations to make the suspected that are considered
guilty to confess. To do this they first isolate the suspect in a small room to
increase their anxiety and their need to escape. Then the police demonstrates
negative and positive incentives. The police starts pressuring the suspect to
feel guilty by making accusation, overriding objections, and showing real or
false evidence. The police also does not accept denials or alibis and makes the
suspect feel hopeless. This type of interrogation lasts for hours and some
people are even deprived from food and water. Police even threatens the suspect
with a harsh consequence if the suspect denies an accusation. As a positive
incentive the police also shows sympathy and moral justification, and lessens
the severity of the crime leading for the suspect to confess as an only way to
escape. Police do this by saying they would have done the same in a certain
situation and that the crime was provoked, an accident, or peer pressured (Kassin,
2009 p.1). Police know how to manipulate a person into thinking that it is in
their best interest to confess, so they can escape the interrogation. The
suspects want to escape because they been held for several hours and sometimes
with no food or water like stated before. The suspects also feel like they have no
choice but to confess because they are not given the opportunity to defend
themselves because the police does not accept it and overrides the suspects’
defense. The police also makes it seem like if the suspect confess there would
not be a serious consequence because the police “sympathizes” with the suspect.
This cause there to be innocent people to be convicted.
In the Marvin Anderson case Police
handled the whole case wrong because they did all the incorrect procedures in
the eyewitness testimony. In the case a women was raped and the information she
gave was that it was a colored man who stated that he had a white girlfriend.
Police made Marvin Anderson a suspect because he was colored and had a white
girlfriend. The police obtained a color photo of Marvin Anderson and it was the
only color photo in the array of black and white pictures to be selected by the
victim. Then Marvin ended up being the only person in the lineup that was also
in the array of pictures and ended up being chosen. Anderson served 15 years in
prison and then was proven innocent by DNA testing (Eyewitness
Misidentification, 2015 p.1). Police were not fair to Anderson in the case
because they were being bias just because he was colored and had a white
girlfriend. Police excluded him out in the array of photos because it was the
only colored one. They excluded him in the lineup also because he was the only
one that was also in the array of photos. This case shows that police can have
an effect in eyewitness testimonies and send innocent people to jail because of
wrong tactics used by them.
When DNA testing
became available in the late 1980s, more than 250 innocent people became
exonerated by post-conviction DNA testing.
Of the first 250 people who were exonerated, 68% were rape cases, 9% were
convicted of murder, 21% were convicted of both murder and rape, and 5% were
convicted of robbery. Seventeen of these people were sentenced to death. Eighty
were sentenced to life in prison. These people served an average of thirteen
years in prison. They were typically in their twenties when they were
convicted. Twenty-four were juveniles and at least eighteen were mentally
disabled. In the DNA exonerations 45% of the 250 post-convictions (112 cases),
the test results identified the real culprit (Garrett, 2011 p. 5) This show
that hundreds of people were falsely accused of a crime and that the system was
not 100% accurate. Like stated before eyewitness testimonies are inaccurate
that can lead to false convictions. Police tactics is another major factor that
is convicting innocent people, especially young and mentally disabled who are
easily manipulated into confessing because of the police tactics used.
There are hundreds
of falsely accused people because of eyewitness testimonies and police tactics.
In eyewitness testimonies psychological factors cause eyewitness testimonies to
be inaccurate. This was proven in the Loftus and Palmer study where misleading
questions was used to change a person’s view on an incident. Also in the study
done by Clifford and Scott where the results showed that people tend to
remember less in a stressful event. Another study that was done by Bartlett
called ‘War of the Ghosts’ proved that reconstructive memory can have an effect
on how we remember things based on our personal experiences. Police tactics was
another factor that cause false convictions. They pressured people to confess
by not accepting denials and at the same time made the suspect comfortable
confessing by sympathizing with them. Also, in the Marvin Anderson case police
were bias and conducted a wrong procedure in the police lineup that led to a
false imprisonment. Overall there were many evidences that proved that
eyewitness testimonies and police tactics caused false imprisonment.
References
Adam, L. (2011, August 23). Often
Wrong but Rarely in Doubt: Eyewitness IDs Will Get a
Garrett, B. (2011). Convicting the
innocent where criminal prosecutions go wrong. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Kassin, S., & Drizin, S. (2009,
July 15). Police-Induced Confessions: Risk Factors and Recommendations. Retrieved May 21, 2015, from http://web.williams.edu/Psychology/Faculty/Kassin/files/White
Paper online (09).pdf