Eyewitness Testimony
Thesis: Due to misleading information in eyewitness
testimonies many innocent people are put
in jail.
I.
Eyewitness Testimonies
A.
What is eyewitness testimony
B.
Factors that effect misleading information
II.
Topic sentence: There are various psychological factors that cause eyewitness
to be inaccurate.
A. Supporting
detail: "Clifford and Scott (1978) found that people who saw a film of a
violent attack remembered fewer of the 40 items of information about the
event than a control group who saw a less stressful version." (Mcleod,
2009).
B. Concluding
sentence: A factor that also effects eyewitness testimonies is the Loftus and
Palmer study.
III.
Topic sentence: In the Loftus and Palmer study it proves that eyewitness
testimony can be unreliable due to leading questions.
A. Supporting
detail: "If someone is exposed to new information during the interval
between witnessing the event and recalling it, this new information may have
marked effects on what they recall. The original memory can be modified,
changed or supplemented."
B. oncluding
sentence: Police is another factor that can also cause false confessions in
eyewitness testimonies.
IV.
Topic sentence: Police have a great effect on eyewitness testimonies because
they can hint at a eyewitness to select a suspect that may be innocent.
A. Supporting
detail: The police can give misleading questions to an eyewitness and cause
imprisonment to people that innocent. There have been many innocent people that
were exonerated by DNA evidence that were convicted by eyewitness testimonies.
B. Concluding
sentence: One example that relates to this was in the Marvin Anderson case.
Police convicted an innocent person in a rape case.
V. In
the Marvin Anderson case Police handled the whole case wrong because they did
all the wrong procedures in the eyewitness testimony.
A. Supporting
detail: The police obtained a color photo of Marvin Anderson and it was the
color photo in the array of black and white pictures to be selected by the
victim. Then Marvin ended up being the only person in the lineup that was also
in the array of pictures and ended up being chosen. Later on after serving 15
years in prison he was proven innocent by DNA testing.
B. Concluding
sentence: Overall based on the case it was shown that police can have an effect
in eyewitness testimonies.
VI. Eyewitness Testimony
A.
The proof why eyewitness testimony is inaccurate
B.
Discuss the studies done against eyewitness testimonies
No comments:
Post a Comment