Bohannon, J. (2014, October 3). How
reliable is eyewitness testimony? Scientists weigh in. Retrieved March 31, 2015, from http://news.sciencemag.org/policy/2014/10/how- reliable-eyewitness-testimony-scientists-weigh
This article discusses
how eyewitness testimonies are not a reliable source in court because police
have an influence on the witnesses. They hint at the witness to select a
perpetrator at a police lineup. The police should have a double blind
scientific experiment at a lineup so neither the police or witness knows that
the suspect is in the lineup. The psychologist Loftus even believes that there
should be no police involved because it wrongfully convicts people. There are
a lot of people that are exonerated by
DNA evidence there were convicted by eyewitness testimony that may have been
influenced by police.
The article is reliable
because it is from a science website. The author even quotes Loftus, who is a
psychologist at the University of California. She gives her option on
eyewitness testimonies and the great affect the police have on it. This is the
same person that did the famous study, Loftus and Palmer. The article is
biased, but shows evidence to why it should be because of all the bad outcomes
of eyewitness testimonies. The article gave important information like the
amount of people being affected by eyewitness testimonies that could help me
back my thesis.
Eyewitness Misidentification. (n.d.).
Retrieved March 31, 2015, from http://www.innocenceproject.org/causes-wrongful-conviction/eyewitness- misidentification
In this article it
tells a story of a man who was wrongfully convicted of rape because of a poor
eyewitness testimony. The police did not make it fair for the person that was
convicted in the police lineup. This led him to be in prison for fifteen years
while being innocent. He was finally proven innocent by a DNA test. The article
also discusses about all the wrong procedures done in an eyewitness testimony
and the solutions that could prevent wrongful convictions.
The article is a
reliable source because it actually uses a real case that ocurred where an
eyewitness testimony sent an innocent man to jail.. The article is also useful
because it lists the problems of eyewitnesses and the solutions it can have.
The article also discusses reforms and scientific evidence that allows it to
support its claims. The article taught me a lot about the studies that were
made back then of eyewitnesses. With all the this information provided the
article can help me prove my point of eyewitnesses being unreliable.
Eyewitness
Testimony | Simply Psychology. (2009). Retrieved March 26, 2015, from http://www.simplypsychology.org/eyewitness-testimony.html
In this article the author explains the psychological factors that cause
eyewitness testimony to be inaccurate. The factors include stress,
reconstructive memory, and weapon focus, . In certain situations, people who
witnessed a violent event that caused stress were more likely to not remember
some information in the event. People who witnessed an event that was not as
violent and did not cause so much stress were able to remember more information
from the event. In reconstructive memory people remember events in schemes,
which is stored unfamiliar information we obtain into something we can make
sense of with prior knowledge we have about the world. This results in
unreliable eyewitness testimony. Weapon focus was another factor discussed and
it showed that when a weapon was involved in an event people were only able to
focus in the weapon and not have enough information on the criminal.
In the article Eyewitness Testimony the author supports its
arguments by citing his claims with psychological studies that have been made
based on eyewitness Testimonies. The author also used references and a video.
The article also contains objective information stating that there were cases
where people were able to give all accurate information in a stressful event.
This article will be useful because of the psychological explanation it
provides backing up my argument in my paper. The author of this article also
gave a link to another article he made discussing a study that supports his
argument on eyewitness testimony. I plan
to use it too because it is a reliable source just like this one.
Loftus and
Palmer | Simply Psychology. (2010). Retrieved March 26, 2015, from http://www.simplypsychology.org/loftus-palmer.html
In this article the author discusses the Loftus and Palmer study that
suggests that if someone is given new information between witnessing an event,
then recalling it, they might change on what they recall. Also, misleading
questions can have the same effect. In the first experiment, the wording of a
question can lead a person to think they saw something different in an event.
For example, in this study, students were asked to view a video of a car
accident. Then they were asked how fast the car was going by using certain
verbs like contacted, hit and smashed. The students that were asked how fast
were the cars driving when they smashed each other stated it was 40mph as
oppose to when asked how fast the cars were driving when they came into
contact, where the students stated it was 31mph.
In this article the author based his conclusions on the Loftus and Palmer
study that was made based on eyewitness testimonies. This is a famous study in
psychology on the topic of eyewitness testimonies, which can be reliable. He
also had references to prove that his statements were supported and valid. He
even used charts and pictures that showed the results to the Loftus and Palmer
study. The article also, has objective information stating that another study
showed that the Loftus and Palmer study is not as accurate based on the
participants used and it's not actually demonstrating a real life accident as
oppose to only show a video of a car accident, which can make the source
limited in a way. Overall the article proved a valid point where people can be
misled in certain situations with a misleading question or information.
No comments:
Post a Comment